Yes, Walt Whitman did show us that lists could be put to poetical purpose. Nonetheless, I think we have to give Billy Joel the Atomic Turkey Award for Least Inspired Opening Words to Any Song for All Time with:
Harry Truman, Doris Day....
Porridger’s Almanack (Breakfast of Ganglions)
… and there are consequences to breaking the heart of a murderous bastard.
— David Carradine in Kill Bill
If The Roxy Performances had been Great Unexpextations (and it was) There was Absolutely No Surprise to my bringing in the One Size Fits All 50th Anniversary box. Quoth Zappa: I spent a long time on this album. I was in the studio for four months, ten to fourteen hours a day.
After the original album, Disc 1 contains Additional Sizes: Session Outtakes and Vault Oddities. A Rough Mix of “Inca Roads,” three tracks of “Ralph Stuffs His Shoes,” which was the working title of “Can’t Afford [None]” and then the Instrumental Mix, Master Take of “Can’t Afford No Shoes” (the lyrics not yet finalized.) Altogether an interesting work-in-progress to listen to.
Take 6 of the Basic Tracks of “Sofa № 1,” followed by an early mix of the Master Take.
Disc 2 is therefore headed Additional Sizes: Session Outtakes and Vault Oddities continued. Illuming to hear “Evelyn, a Modified Dog” being workshopped. The outsized presence on this disc is “San Ber’dino,” with two tracks under its working title of “Bitch, Bitch, Bitch” as well as three Rough Mixes. One notable early idea was, Napoleon Murphy Brock singing it in first person. Don van Vliet’s harmonica is in on II & III, As is Johnny “Guitar” Watson. We enjoy Rough Mixes, too of “Something/Anything,” (proto-“Andy,” with Brock singing) “Andy” (Watson singing) and “Sofa № 2.”
Discs 3 & 4 present a 28 September 1974 concert in Rotterdam’s Sports Palace Ahoy with the OSFA sextet, and as One Size Fits All would be released in June of 1975, both “Inca Roads” and “Florentine Pogen” are still in “Road Test” mode. Closing out Disc 4 are two bonus tracks from a 25 September 1974 concert in Göteborg, Sweden (“Ralph Stuffs His Shoes” and “Po-Jama People”). From the top, though: the “Tush Tush Tush” riffing is entirely in line with what we consumers of “The Helsinki Concert” a/k/a You Can’t Do That on Stage Anymore, Vol. 2 might expect. “Stinkfoot” is straightforward save a coy wink to us classical aficionados in that the place he knows is around the corner “by Edo de Waart’s house.” The characteristic individual invention and collective chemistry of Geo. Duke & Zappa makes each iteration of “Inca Roads” a new delight. also some very nice percussion by Ruth Underwood & al. for the outro. Zappa then explains the scheme of “Approximate” before its execution. To know it better is to love it all the more. Also, a juicy wah-wah-modulated solo. A “Cosmik Debris” of a more pesante character than average and with a glancing “Ralph Stuffs His Shoes” reference, a delicious electric piano solo giving way to Zappa, whose solo begins in quietude and ultimately waxes majestical. Zappa then introduces “Florentine Pogen” as “Chester’s Gorilla.” Rather than make myself unfittingly tedious through repetition, I remark simply that each new (to one’s ears) guitar solo is a fresh delight because Zappa never phoned it in. There then follow a beeswax-sweet “Montana” and after an Intermission (not reflected on the CD a no less dulcet “RDNZL” Another element this concert has in common with the above-mentioned Helsinki event is, “Dupree’s Paradise” opens with finger cymbals, and Geo. Duke pretending to hurt himself. Between the intro and “Dupree’s Paradise” proper is Geo. transition to an improv “Blind Mice Blues,” a not insignificant digression. The two parts of “Dupree’s Paradise” proper (with “We Can Share a Love” interpolated—yes, more continuity with Helsinki) runs a grand 27 minutes and a half. In Part 1, Geo. uses a flute-ish timbre on the synthesizer which combines intriguingly with Napoleon Murphy Brock’s genuine flute. Tom Fowler takes a nice bass solo (or rather, duet with Chester Thompson.) Probably stating the obvious, but the joy in “Dupree’s Paradise” is always the emergents of the day as much as the “head.” Great gritty solo in “Pygmy Twylyte.” The “Room Service” tomfoolery is fun but inessential. The same description probably does no great injustice to the Swedish diptych, “Ralph Stuffs His Shoes” and “Po-Jama People.” whose chief interest consists in their being “road tests” preparatory to the album. On the dolby atmos mix of the album and the bonus surround tracks (“Sofa № 1” and “San Ber’dino” which are included on the fifth (blu-ray) disc, I have not the equipment to experience nor therefore to comment on. The video bonus, “Inca Roads” and “Florentine Pogen,” videotaped 27 Aug 1974 at LA’s KCET-TV studios are both impressive and fun, for all the expected reasons. And the array of instruments in both Geo. Duke’s keyboard station, and Ruth Underwood’s percussion section (dig her playing duck call near the end of “F. P.”) speaks both to the supple dexterity and mental agility of those brilliant musicians, and to Zappa’s resourcefulness as a composer. And for those of us who have loved the album for decades, and wondering what in blazes “Chester’s gorilla” was about: Marty Perellis (Zappa’s road manager) in (yep) a gorilla costume, with a comb and a mantel clock. It can be witnessed but probably never satisfactorily explained. And who wants too much satisfactory explanation in the world of FZ, anyway? One of my biggest takeaways from absorption of the Roxy and OSFA boxes is, how horribly I had undervalued Napoleon Murphy Brock as a flutist.
